ALLIED EMERGENCY SERVICES COURT DOCUMENT ARCHIVE · THE HAIL FILES
Archive › Documents › Plaintiffs' Reply in Support of Renewed Motion to Enforcce a

FOSTER V. STATE FARM

Plaintiffs' Reply in Support of Renewed Motion to Enforcce and for Sanctions (Redacted) (Foster v. State Farm, 2026-11-06)

Cleveland County District Court, CJ-2023-1426 · Filed 2026-11-06 · 48 pages · Download the PDF

What this document says (first page, verbatim)

IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF CLEVELAND COUNTY STATE OF OKLAHOMA FILED DISTRICT COURT DON and BRENDA FOSTER, CLEVELAND COUNTY, OKLAHOMA Plaintiff, November 6, 2026 10:17 AM MARILYN WILLIAMS, COURT CLERK V. Case Number CJ-2023-1426 STATE FARM FIRE AND CASUALTY COMPANY, DAVID CAMP, and RITA WALLENBERG INSURANCE AGENCY, INC., Case No. CJ-2023-1426 Hon. Thad Balkman Defendants. PLAINTIFFS’ REPLY IN SUPPORT OF RENEWED MOTION TO ENFORCE AND FOR SANCTIONS REDACTED FOR PUBLIC FILING

Key terms in this filing

sanction ×16 · deposition ×8 · denial ×1 · bad faith ×1

Notable passages

PAGE 3 · bad faith, sanction

… ‘clearly wrong.’” Barnett v. Simmons, 2008 OK 100, § 17, 197 P.3d 12, 19. Only severe sanctions “such as dismissal or default judgment” required a finding of “bad faith.” Jd. at § 18. Regardless, “to be ‘willful’ the failure need not necessarily be accompanied by wrongful intent. It is sufficient if it is conscious or intentional, not accidental or involuntary.” State of Ohio v. Crofters, Inc., 75 F.R.D. 12, 24 (D. …

PAGE 6 · sanction, deposition

… returned to state its refusal to complete the deposition, despite the Court’s order. Ex. 4 at 323:5-335:22. This conduct precisely demonstrates the need for a sanction requirmg State Farm’s previously-deposed witnesses to appear live at trial. Neither Plaintiffs nor the Court should be forced to engage in additional depositions necessitated by discovery misconduct. Those witnesses can complete their testimony before …

PAGE 4 · sanction, deposition

… November of 2025. Compare Mtn. at 1-3 with Hicks v. Cent. Oklahoma United Methodist Ret. Facility, Inc., 2017 OK CIV APP 23, 4 7, 423 P.3d 684, 692 (upholding sanctions where trial court found failure to obey discovery orders necessitated “trial delays and multiple discovery hearings’’). Culpability. State Farm knowingly failed to meet the deadline it asked this Court to set after multiple extensions. And despite kn …

Search every page of this and 202 other documents: full-text search · Context: Trial Watch calendar

← Amended Notice of Hearing (State of Oklahoma v. State Farm, 2026-11-03Plaintiffs’ Response to Defendant State Farm’s Motion to Strike Plaint →

Get notified when new documents unseal

The Hursh v. State Farm jury trial is set for December 7: follow it on Trial Watch Live. One email per development — filings and unsealed documents only, no marketing, unsubscribe in one click.

Your address is used only for these alerts and is never shared or added to any sales list.

Excerpts are verbatim OCR text from the public court record and may contain OCR errors; refer to the PDF for the authoritative text, or obtain certified copies from the court clerk for court use. Allegations in filings are claims made by parties in litigation, not findings of fact.

About the host: Allied Emergency Services is a licensed storm-damage restoration contractor serving Illinois, Wisconsin, Indiana and Michigan — not a law firm, insurance adjuster or public adjuster, and this page is not legal or insurance advice. We inspect, document, provide insurance-ready repair estimates and complete repairs; coverage decisions always belong to you and your insurer. 24/7: (800) 792-0212

Archive home · All documents · Search · Trial Watch · Trial Watch Live · For journalists · alliedemergencyservices.com
Allied Emergency Services, Inc. · Hosted as a public service · Documents are unaltered public records