WEST V. STATE FARM FIRE & CASUALTY CO.
Comanche County District Court, CJ-2025-135 · Filed 2026-10-23 · 32 pages · Download the PDF
IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF COMANCHE COUNTY STATE OF OKLAHOMA NEIL and LACY WEST, FILED DISTRICT COURT COMANCHE ) ) COUNTY, OKLAHOMA October 23, 2026 4:59 PM Plaintiff ROBERT aintitts, MORALES, COURT Case Number CJ-2025-135 VS. ) Case No. CJ-2025-135 ) STATE FARM FIRE AND CASUALTY COMPANY and NANCY HOLCOMB INS. _ AGENCY, INC, ) ) Judge Sheperd ) ) Defendants. ) STATE FARM FIRE AND CASUALTY COMPANY’S NOTICE OF SUPPLEMENTAL AUTHORITY Defendant, State Farm Fire and Casualty Company, has pending before the Court its Amended Motion for Summary Judgment which was argued on October 22, 2026 and which the Court took under advisement. …
bad faith ×33 · denial ×32 · summary judgment ×24 · roof replacement ×21 · sanction ×6 · deposition ×3 · Xactimate ×1
PAGE 14 · denial, bad faith, summary judgment
… plaintiff was on notice when responding to the motion for summary judgment that such discovery would not be permitted in this case and the magistrate judge has denied plaintiff's motion to compel. Plaintiff previously filed a motion to extend scheduling order deadlines, including the discovery cutoff, and the Court specifically rejected plaintiff's request to reopen discovery due to plaintiff's failure to diligently …
PAGE 3 · denial, bad faith, summary judgment, roof replacement
… gation. Plaintiff seems to be making an argument that the evidence in favor of total roof replacement was so overwhelming that no reasonable insurer could have denied her claim. Dkt. # 79, at 26, The Court has already determined that State Farm relied on a legitimate coverage dispute as a basis to partially deny plaintiff’s claims for wind and hail damage, and this necessarily implies that the evidence was not so one …
PAGE 10 · denial, bad faith, summary judgment, roof replacement
… a decision on plaintiff's insurance claim. Dkt. #55. Plaintiff responds that the underpayment of her claim was part ofa larger plan or scheme to systematically deny or underpay valid wind and hail damage claims and, specifically as to plaintiff's claim, State Farm conducted a “woefully inadequate investigation” and ignored evidence in the record showing that the only viable repair was total roof replacement. Dkt. #7 …
Search every page of this and 59 other filings: full-text search · Context: Trial Watch calendar
← 20261022-1067128717-notice-of-hearing.pdf20261023-1067067691-defendant-state-farm-fire-casualty-company-s-reply →
The next document wave is expected around September 19; trial begins December 7. One email per development — filings and unsealed documents only, no marketing, unsubscribe in one click.
Your address is used only for these alerts and is never shared or added to any sales list.
Excerpts are verbatim OCR text from the public court record and may contain OCR errors; refer to the PDF for the authoritative text, or obtain certified copies from the court clerk for court use. Allegations in filings are claims made by parties in litigation, not findings of fact.
About the host: Allied Emergency Services is a licensed storm-damage restoration contractor serving Illinois, Wisconsin, Indiana and Michigan — not a law firm, insurance adjuster or public adjuster, and this page is not legal or insurance advice. We inspect, document, provide insurance-ready repair estimates and complete repairs; coverage decisions always belong to you and your insurer. 24/7: (800) 792-0212